The Devil Wears Prada review by Mike Long
"Chick flick" is a term which gets thrown around a lot today. The typical definition refers to a movie which centers on a woman or a group of women and explores the unique issues/problems which hinder these women and how they must overcome them. (Also, the names "Sandra Bullock" and "Meg Ryan" have become synonymous with “chick flicks”.) But, is it possible for a movie to be about women and set in a woman’s world which isn’t a “chick flick”? The genre-bending The Devil Wears Prada may be the film which achieves this seemingly impossible feat.

Andy Sachs (Anne Hathaway) is a newly graduated young woman who has come to New York to pursue a career in journalism. The human resources department of a magazine conglomerate sends her for an interview at Runway magazine, the most popular fashion mag in the world. Unfortunately, Andy knows nothing about fashion. Andy quickly meets the formidable editor of Runway, Miranda Priestly (Meryl Streep). Due to the fact that Andy doesn’t look like the typical model wannabes who apply to be her assistant, Miranda decides to hire Andy, much to the chagrin of the other assistant, Emily (Emily Blunt). Despite the fact that Andy doesn’t quite grasp the Runway world, she is excited about the opportunity.

However, Andy soon learns that working for Miranda Priestly is no dream job. Miranda is a true perfectionist and only wants things to be done her way. She refers to Andy as “Emily” and is constantly making dozens of demands at once. If Andy isn’t out getting coffee (seemingly non-stop), she’s fetching clothing samples from a famous designer or doing something personal for Miranda. At first, Andy sees Miranda as evil, but she soon learns that Miranda only wants the best out of people. Thus, Andy begins to adapt, not only in her work ethic, but in her appearance. But, as her performance begins to improve, her private life, especially with her boyfriend, Nate (Adam Grenier), starts to suffer.

So, by this point you’re thinking, “What? Didn’t he say that this wasn’t a ‘chick flick‘? You’ve got a girl working for a bitchy boss at a fashion magazine and it’s not a ‘chick flick‘? Well, I suppose in some ways it is. Most of the main characters in the film are female, and the males here merely fills certain roles in the story. The movie certainly does focus on clothing and the importance of fashion. The Devil Wears Prada also makes many comments on the way in which women work together and the way in which they treat one another -- which often involves a great deal of back-stabbing.

Yet, along with all of that, there is a story that certainly falls outside of the typical “chick flick” mode. The movie puts a slightly new twist on the clichéd “underdog” story. Typically (especially in sports films), we have someone who is underqualified who must prove themselves in order to pursue their dreams. With Andy, we have a character who is overqualified to be an assistant who is constantly running errands, and who doesn’t have any particular aspirations to work in the world of fashion. But, as the story progresses, we learn that Andy is a true go-getter. As she desires to live up to Miranda’s very high expectations, Andy devotes herself to the job. She learns the proper way to do things and begins to dress the part as well. During Andy’s transformation, the audience begins to realize that Miranda isn’t necessarily evil, she’s simply a successful businesswoman who expects the best from everyone. Despite the fact that Miranda is seen as the queen of her particular industry, her boss is a man and the film implies that even she struggles to maintain her regal air in this cut-throat business.

Thus, there are parts of The Devil Wears Prada which are more accessible to a wide audience than the standard “chick flick”. Even if one knows nothing about (or cares nothing for) the fashion industry, many of us have had overbearing bosses who made outrageous demands, which makes the film more relatable. And even if we don’t agree with the fact that Andy would shirk her personal life to bust her ass for this ice queen, it’s hard to not admire her determination.

The overall presentation of The Devil Wears Prada places it outside of the “chick flick” realm, but the film’s plotting also moves it away from easy genre classification. If pressed, I would call the film a dramedy, but even that’s not accurate. The movie has some funny moments, and it certainly has some dramatic moments, but it never commits to either. One of the most interesting things about The Devil Wears Prada is the narrative structure. Simply put, outside of Andy’s job and social situation, there are no other dramatic twists, and I really admire this. So often movies and TV shows introduce unrealistic situations simply to heighten the drama. With this movie, we simply watch Andy evolve and grow at her job. There are no unnecessary villains or crises -- just the simple story of a fish out of water trying to prove herself. A minor plot twist arrives during the final act, but it’s nothing compared to what we’re used to seeing. Kudos to the makers of The Devil Wears Prada for understanding that an interesting premise and interesting characters can actually carry a movie.

If you were to ask me, “Hey, want to watch a movie about a woman trying to make it at a fashion magazine?”, my normal reaction would be “No”...probably followed by some profanity. But, The Devil Wears Prada is an enjoyable film which shrugs off any “chick flick” notions to be a well-rounded movie. Of course, the presence of the gorgeous Anne Hathaway and the talented Meryl Streep (who will probably be nominated for this role) don’t hurt the film. It’s still true that this movie isn’t for everyone, but for a movie with no explosions or car chases, it wasn’t bad.

The Devil Wears Prada struts onto DVD courtesy of 20th Century Fox Home Entertainment. The film is coming to DVD in two separate releases, one full-frame and the other widescreen. For the purposes of this review, only the widescreen version was viewed. The film has been letterboxed at 2.35:1 and the transfer is enhanced for 16 x 9 TVs. The transfer looks very good, as the image is sharp and clear. The image shows just a slight hint of grain and no defects from the source material. The picture is well-balanced, as it’s never too bright or too dark and the framing appears to be accurate. The colors look very good -- the movie has been shot in a very natural style, and the colors of the various clothes are allowed to stand out. The DVD carries a Dolby Digital 5.1 audio track which offers clear dialogue and sound effects. The stereo effects are very good and show excellent speaker placement. The surround sound effects are limited to street scenes and musical cues, but they are noticeable.

The Devil Wears Prada DVD contains a limited number of extras, but they are interesting. We start with an AUDIO COMMENTARY, which features director David Frankel, producer Wendy Finerman, costume designer Patricia Field, writer Aline Brosh McKenna, editor Mark Livolsi, and director of photography Florian Ballhaus. This is a fact-filled, yet fairly standard commentary. The group gives us a lot of details about location, story, and actors, and will answers many questions which the viewer may have. But it’s all quite dry and there doesn’t seem to be a lot of chemistry between the speakers. “The Trip to the Big Screen” (12 minutes) features Frankel, Finerman, and McKenna talking about the stories trip through scripting to filming. The problem is that the source novel is mentioned many times, but we don’t get any details on what was changed from the book. “NYC and Fashion” (6 minutes) explores the importance of fashion and how it’s portrayed in the film, and the use of real New York City locations. In “Fashion Visionary Patricia Field” (9 minutes), Field talks about her life and career in fashion, and how shot got into being a costume designer. “Getting Valentino” (3 minutes) describes how the famous fashion designer found his way into the film. “Boss from Hell” (2 minutes) is a simply promo featurette. The DVD contains 15 DELETED SCENES which run about 22 minutes, and can be viewed with optional commentary with Frankel and Livolsi. Most of these are simply extended scenes and there are no revelations or new subplots here, but there are some very nice and funny moments. The extras are rounded out by a GAG REEL (5 minutes) and the THEATRICAL TRAILER for the film.

Mike Long Rating: 8 1 Jackass 1 Jackass 1 Jackass 1 Jackass 1 Jackass 1 Jackass 1 Jackass 1 Jackass
Number of Hits: 6112 Recent: 2231 Review by:Mike Long
Unleashed the review of Hangmans Curse on Jackass Critics. Spawned a throng of teenaged girls to use the JAC site as their personal bulletin board.
Average Rating:5.685900
Reviewers Last 5 Reviews

Epic Movie - 1 out of 10
Little Children - 8 out of 10
That Thing You Do! - 7 out of 10
Catch & Release - 6 out of 10
Night at the Museum - 8 out of 10
Number of
Movies Reviewed
:
347
Median Rating:6
Mode Rating:7
Reader Ratings:4.794900
Jackass Average:6.253700
Reviewer is more stingy than your average Jackass.


Similar reviews:
The Devil Wears Prada by Tom Blain - 6 out of 10. (Same movie, different reviewer)
Ella Enchanted by Mike Long - 6 out of 10. (Same actor)
Havoc by Matt Fuerst - 6 out of 10. (Same actor)
The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement by Mike Long - 2 out of 10. (Same actor)
The Princess Diaries by Mike Long - 6 out of 10. (Same actor)
Lemony Snicket's Series of Unfortunate Events by The Grim Ringler - 8 out of 10. (Same actor)
The Manchurian Candidate by Mike Long - 6 out of 10. (Same actor)
Shall We Dance? by Mike Long - 3 out of 10. (Same actor)
The Core by Mike Long - 5 out of 10. (Same actor)
VISITOR REVIEWS
Average User Rating is a 0
No reader reviews yet
New Review

VISITOR COMMENTS
DrunkyNovember 17th, 2006Reply
Wow when is the jackasscritics slumber party? You guys can make smores and braid each others' hair.
TomNovember 17th, 2006Reply
One point that should be made is that the boss is female but she is far from being gender specific. In her professional state, that never really comes into play. She is all business. I think that aspect sort of removes the movie from being a chick flick.

Also, just because the two main actors are women, I dont think that qualifies this movie as being a pure chick flick. I think the DVD cover and poster do market it to that crowd though (even though it exceeds that).

Just to give drunky more perspective. i can see how someone like him could judge an entire movie solely by its poster. Knowing drunky I could also see how he could try to hold up his end of an argument based soley on a movie poster and having no other knowledge of the movie. And knowing drunky I could also see him huddled around a small TV-DVD player in a dark room or closet watching this movie, feeling riddled with guilt as he enjoys every minute; identifying with Anne Hathaway's character.

DrunkyNovember 17th, 2006Reply
Tom it's not in your best interest to call for an assembly of the facts in regards to this matter. You should lie there quietly and take your due punishment.

We all know Meryl Streep is a rich man's Bea Arthur and a fan favorite of lesbians everywhere.

Young Anne Hathaway has somehow already typecast herself as the go-to-girl for movies that are made solely for females. What are her roles thus far? Let's see... The Princess Diaries, The Princess Diaries 2, Ella Enchanted and The Devil Wears Prada. I'm sure those are all among your personal favorites. Oh guess what? She's currently working on 2 films by the names of "Becoming Jane" and "The Women". Those sound like your kind of movies too.

Let me do a search on amazon.com for the novel The Devil Wears Prada. Now let me look under the section "Customers who bought this item also bought:" and see what Tom considers enjoyable reading... Oh these are excellent!... "The Nanny Diaries", "Bergdorf Blondes", "The Undomestic Goddess" & "Confessions of a Shopaholic".

I can't make this stuff up. That's minus 20 man-points for illogically trying to defend yourself - again.
    Matt FuerstNovember 17th, 2006
 I tend to side with Drunky in that I certainly am not secure enough to go out and rent The Devil Wears Prada from a video store un poco solo, however... I do need to point out two factoids before Drunky and Tom continue their battle.

(1) Drunky watched the JAPANESE version of Shall We Dance. Which is both (A) a chick flick and (B) a Japanese original chick flick that was remade in the US with Richard Gere.

(2) Anne Hathaway actually exposed her hooties and did naughty things in Havoc. I'd recommend reading the Havoc review on Jackass Critics because it's really well written.
    TomNovember 17th, 2006
 ....remade with Richard Gere AND Jennifer Lopez AND Susan Sarandon.

...and I was trapped on a 13 hour plane ride and went through three movies already. I didn't shell out money to see it.

Going back to Drunky: I heard rumors that the Japanese version is even more 'vaginal' but maybe our drunken Man Law expert could give us breakdown. A few more questions to drunky: When watching chick flicks do you find it more rewarding to get that hard to find original with subtitles? How much butter do you put on your popcorn? A LOT or A LOT PLUS MORE?
DrunkyNovember 17th, 2006Reply
Dammit Fuersty. Well I don't know about the U.S. version, but the Japanese version centered around the guy the whole time at least, it had a very Lost in Translation type of mood going the whole time, not that I'm saying whether I liked it or not.

Anyway in my defense I don't read Japanese very well, I thought the cover read "Shall We Blow Stuff Up Dudes."
    Matt FuerstNovember 18th, 2006
 "Shall We Blow Stuff Up Dudes" got a laugh, but I still don't forgive you for disparaging Ms. Hathaway's character. You insinuate she plays only girly parts, when I've seen for myself that's not the case my man! Defend yourself!
Enter your comment: (No HTML allowed)
Name:
REPEAT NUMBER:
<-You must enter NUMBER for post to save!
E-Mail
(Optional):
Comment: